Saints Commits Few Sins: Saints Row 2 Reviewed


                                                      Eminem responds to the critics of his last album.

In 2006, a wake-up call was delivered to Grand Theft Auto developer, Rockstar. For far too long, ballistic combat in the GTA games had evolved little, remaining wonky and unintuitive. We recall playing GTA 3: San Andreas, and cursing at the screen after the game repeatedly locked on to the wrong enemy. With GTA 4 still years away, and without a single screenshot to tide them over, gamers became impatient for an urban, gangster-centric sandbox game. When Saints Row was first announced, many were rightfully skeptical of the title, after seeing a multitude of disappointing GTA clones. Fortunately, developer Volition listened to the criticisms of GTA and responded accordingly- gone was the inept combat system, skillfully replaced with a targeting reticule. Saints Row also blended the two disjointed play styles of GTA;  missions attempted to capture the exuberance of those freeform killing sprees the Rockstar’s series was famous for.

Saints Row 2 picks up right where the last game ended, with the main character of the game awaking from a coma. Before the first mission begins, players are given an elaborate set of tools to construct their avatar. Not only can the gamer adjust the physical appearance of the protagonist, but they can also choose from three different accents for each of the two genders. As the game begins, you learn that in your absence, the Saints have lost their foothold on the city of Stillwater. Your goal is to reclaim the different districts, as your restore the splintered Saints gang.


                                            “Call me a wiener again, and I’ll turn you into hamburger meat”.

Unlike other sandbox style games that have put restrictions on cooperative gameplay, Saints Row 2 allows two players to carry out their urban bedlam without requiring players to be tethered. Friends dropped into our story mode effortlessly, and assisted in some of the brilliantly designed collaborative activities. While the single player game is engaging, the game becomes exponentially more enjoyable with another human.

The game eclipses its sandbox- style competitors in its variety and the ingenuity of missions. Before advancing the main story, players must accumulate enough ‘respect’ earned while playing side missions. Whereas the non-essential tasks are commonly the Achilles’ heel of the genre, they are one of SR2’s greatest strengths. Players are challenged to amass thousands of dollars in property damage, or covering houses in raw sewage. Frequently, we would spend hour-long bursts in a single mini-game, neglecting the main storyline. Thankfully, they are all entertaining and there are no duds in the bunch.


                                                      The game even has Tech-Gaming headquarters in it. 

Graphically, the game isn’t as polished as GTA 4Saint Row 2’s world appears slightly more polygonal, as models seem to use less geometry. While on-screen activity is exceedingly busy, the game displays both the occasional v-sych and framerate falters. Likewise, the city of Stillwater can be inexplicably glitchy. Cars and pedestrians we passed instantly disappeared as we looped around, and we have been trapped in our cars on rare occasions. Overall, some of these offensives are forgivable as the title desperately tries to maximize its open-world environment. Where the game excels is in the small details, from comical facial reactions to the airy clouds that are observed when players take flight. Sonically, SR2’s music palette is diverse and well chosen; Tears for Fears, Everybody Wants to Rule the World, seems especially poignant during our hyper violent maulings.


                                                      Ok, someone cue up Flight of the Valkyries for us

Overall, Saints Row 2 offers players a disk full of mayhem to soak in and explore. While the title can be a blast for a single participant, the cooperative game stands alone as one of the best examples of a two player experience currently available in any game. Just be aware the overall experience comes with its fair share of glitches, a price to pay for all the variety the game offers.

Good: Mission variety, cooperative play, amount of content, Zombie Uprising minigame
Bad: A bit unpolished, where’s our ‘Big Ass Chains’ multiplayer mode?
Ugly: Pop-in, hookers with ‘spare tire’ waistlines.

About Robert Allen

Since being a toddler, Robert Allen has been immersed in video games, anime, and tokusatsu. Currently, his days are spent teaching at two southern California colleges. But his evenings and weekends are filled with STGs, RPGs, and action titles and well at writing for Tech-Gaming since 2007.

80 comments

  1. Man, between this Fable 2 and Fallot I am screwed.

  2. Man, everyone’s saying how glitchy this game is. Why cant devs spend a bit more time with the games?

  3. Got to play this game. I loved the first one. I’m sad to hear the Big Ass Chains are gone.

  4. I hear this one is super violent. Is is really close to an AO rating?

  5. I got tired of the first one real quick. I did like the voice acting in it. Do the same stars return?

  6. My friend spent 45 minutes in the damn char creator. I only got to see the game play for 10. Pop-in looked linda bad.

  7. I was not planning to get this, but now I’m think I might. Thanks for the write up.

  8. Which is better 360 or PS3?

  9. The Artist Known as 7

    I hear you can take off all your clothes and streak. Does it show schlong? that would be funny!

  10. Never played the first one, I look forward to playing this one!

  11. I’ve been looking forward to playing this one. I enjoy sandbox games and really wanted to play Saint’s Row, but didn’t have a 360.

  12. I love how this is like gta, but doesn’t take everything so seriously. It is just fun the mess around.

  13. Sounds like the makers listened to their fans. So I hope for SR3 they fix the bugs.

  14. i love saint row 2 it super fun
    just hope sr3 is even more fun

  15. God hates fat girls

    Did you guys get the collector’s edition? Is is worth the extra scratch?

  16. Nice review. 😀

  17. I have to get it just to be in a hot dog suit. That shit is funny.

  18. Cuz it’s almost Christmas. Thats when most games are sold.

  19. Uh, so close to GTA4, I don’t think I need another gangsta game. They should have let this one go for another six months.

  20. Sounds scrumptious. Nice review DE. Now, I wish some good non-MMO PC games would release.

  21. Will buy before Xmas, I hope.

  22. I hope the next gen will be less glitchy, sadly I think games are getting worse.

  23. damn bruh you make me wanna play it even more now im twisted fable 2 seems tight but sr2? come on tight work

  24. Im still holdout out for Fallout 3.

    I think I can wait on this one.

  25. I would love top play this game. Hopefully it’s better than GTA4

  26. Sound like a great game. I’d also like to know which version is better graphically.

  27. Woohoo.. Zombies 😀

  28. Seems like an over the top GTA game. Too many other games coming out to get this one though.

  29. I’m dome with gangster-type games. Godfather was ok, I guess.

  30. Great review! I still haven’t finshed the first game.

  31. This game is hundreds times better than the previous one. Which was a great game as well.

  32. I have never played the first Saints Row but am a fan of the GTA series. I heard many good things about this second games and this review makes kinda makes me want to pick it up….but when it gets cheaper of course 🙂

  33. Hey, this looks kind of fun. I’ve never played 1, would I need it at all for 2?

  34. I’ve read that the vehicle physics are lame compared to GTA’s….

  35. I really liked the first Saint’s Row. I am looking forward to this one. Unlike GTA 4, I like causing crazy mayhem. I also liked the character creater.

  36. the game has so any mini games, it’s almost impossible to pick which one to play first!

  37. Being able to be a fat Asian lady makes this game worthwhile.

  38. I was thinking of picking this game up. Now I really want to play it.

  39. I passed on the first Saint’s Row but I keep hearing good things about it. Maybe I’ll give this one a go.

  40. Hey the first Saint’s was decent….no GTA killer, but a fun game in it’s own right. This one looks just as good

  41. This game looks like it might be more fun than GTA is anymore, due to it taking itself much less seriously. I’m excited to try it out.

  42. This game is going to give GTA5 some competition later on in the next gen. Saints row 2 was decent but I can see alot of improvements.

  43. Sounds like the missions are much better that the go here and kill this GTA style of play.

  44. The game seems to be doing well. I went to two stores before finding a single copy.

  45. That helicopter pic got me all excited. And after reading the review and comments, I’m super hyped for this game.

  46. Collectors editions are never worth in, IMHO. They make so many, that they are never worth more in the long run, anyways.

  47. Please tell me it has jetpacks.

  48. Man, I’m too broke these days. the Saints will have to wait.

  49. got saints row long time ago – awesome game, but SR2 looks twice as good, it’s gonna be ridiculously good!

  50. I loved the first one. Sad to hear about BAC mode being removed.

  51. nice review!

  52. The original was great. Add more weapons, guns, vehicles, and activities and SR2 could be a sleeper hit. Im gonna get it.

  53. game looks pretty sick, nice review!

  54. i really digg this game. Ill have to look for a cheap copy on the cags.

  55. cool played SR2 at my friends house and it was sick

  56. nice review.
    i may check for this game.

  57. i may have to check for this game.
    nice review

  58. I think I’m getting a bit tired of the sandbox type game. This might be my last one for a while.

  59. Sounds like the only sin is not picking it up.

  60. is that the acropolis in that last picture?

  61. This game is soo much better than GTA its not even funny. Saints Row is just plain fun

  62. I think the Hot Dog costume just sold me on this game.

  63. I wonder if this can give GTA4 a run for its money?

  64. I loved SR1. Was hoping that SR2 would let you use your old SR1 save so you could go get revenge for what happens at the end of that game.

  65. I loved the Saints Row, and SR2 seems to be well improved. I need to rent this asap!

  66. This game looks better than Saints Row. If your a GTA fan you have to give this game a chance. I got Saint’s Row when it first came out and blew my expectations for the game. Definitely going for this one to.

  67. Saints row is pretty fun.

  68. Ewww.. a hotdog with mustard. I must win!

  69. Never played the first Saints Row, but I am interested in this one. =d

  70. Everyone loves mayhem, eh?

  71. Looks pretty fun, but I think Fallout 3 will have enough things for me to do.

  72. This article is making want to play it even more then I wanted before. Can’t wait to get my hands on it.

  73. very nice review, too bad there are too many games that are must haves for me this month. Should have been released a month or 2 earlier

  74. Just finished playing GTA. Not really interested in jumping into a very similar game. I think I’ll crack my Halo 3 disc open that I got originally for X-mas!

  75. Good review. Hope to receive the PS3 version as a Christmas present.

  76. Aww, he’s a hot dog.

  77. Nice Review. Will check this game out and hopefully that ps3 version.

  78. Loved the original, hope this one can live up to GTA Four’s open-world crime game standards.

  79. Glad I read this article because I wasn’t sure if I really wanted this game or not. Definitely convinced me, thanks!@