Beyond the ‘Reel’- Shimano Xtreme Fishing Review

Much like the recreation on which is based on, one of the fundamental difficulties of fishing games is maintaining freshness. Although the tension of reeling in an enormous catch can be thrilling, repeating the same task dozens of times can be a repugnant as week-old catfish. Developer eV Interactive is hoping to solve the conundrum with Shimano Xtreme Fishing, title that incorporates the obligatory rod and reel process, as well as offering bow and spear gun methods.

From the game’s title screen players may participate in Career, Free-Fishing or Multiplayer elements. Despite which trajectory is chosen, the gameplay is remarkable similar, with Free-Fishing eliminating any time constraints and the title’s competitive modes allowing for simultaneous play. Shimano’s mechanics shirk simulation, leaning heavily toward arcade diversion. This sentiment is unabashedly conveyed though the request for players to “choose their weapon”, as hard-rock music blares. Clearly, the word “Xtreme” has come to mean the recycling of decade-old Mortal Kombat clichés.

As the most pedestrian of the title’s pursuits, rod fishing is the least interesting. Players steer their boats to designated areas, and cast-off with a swing of the Wiimote. Since the game’s waterways are teeming with the gilled guys, getting a nibble is both painless and frequent. When a bite happens, gamers are requested to lift the controller to hook the fish, imitating the game’s mode’s main tension. Players use either the “B” button or a sideways spin of the nunchuck to reel in their prospective catch, maintaining a careful balance between not breaking their line and letting the aquatic creature of the hook. Sporadically, players are requested to swing their Wiimote up, left or right- responding without haste or vigor will result in the fish escaping. Once a few fish are landed, the artificiality of the conflict is illuminated. The clash isn’t about bringing the fish onto the boat, but rather reducing the animal’s energy gauge. No matter how close or far from your craft the catch is, the encounter will always be the same- right down to the number of the controller swings required to tire the fish.

Both bow and spear fishing eliminate the requirement to methodically reel in your catch, evoking the feel of an aquatic shooting gallery. While bow fishing takes place above the surface, and spearing is done underwater, both are moderately similar. Players use the Wiimote’s pointer function to aim, while the “B” button launches the projectile. Although smaller fish are landed with a single, accurate shot, larger prey require multiple attacks. The challenge presented by bow fishing is identifying the fish, as they blend in with game’s murky locales. Spearing places the gamer in SCUBA gear, where players are free to roam the environment, toggling between a third and first-person perspective. Strangely, bring in a 300 pound hammerhead shark is no more difficult than a barracuda.

 

Each of the game’s modes feature a glowing monster fish, which presents a larger difficulty in landing, but also a hefty scoring reward. The prize upsets the game’s balance- the single fish can offer more points than a thirty smaller fish. Thankfully, the game’s combo system is interesting, offering players additional rewards for spearing distant fish, or landing consecutive hits.

Although the majority of Shimano’s locations are reasonably detailed, and each of the game’s 50+ types of fish are competently rendered, the game’s sense of depth in when using the rod or bow is underwhelming. By consistently showing the floor, each waterway appears to be only a few feat feet. At least small touches like treasure chests, sunken aircraft or the occasional dragonfly skimming the water’s surface evoke the occasional sense of charm.

Shimano Xtreme Fishing isn’t without its problems. Although the title’s latter stages offer exotic locales and different types of fish to catch, the core mechanics remain remarkably similar. Despite its simplicity, the game’s range of fish-catching options elevate the title over similarly themed diversions on the Wii. Those inclined to do some virtual angling will find amusement in Shimano’s diversion- it’s too bad those moments are fleeting.

About Robert Allen

Since being a toddler, Robert Allen has been immersed in video games, anime, and tokusatsu. Currently, his days are spent teaching at two southern California colleges. But his evenings and weekends are filled with STGs, RPGs, and action titles and well at writing for Tech-Gaming since 2007.

33 comments

  1. Sounds interesting, but I think I’d rather go actual fishing.

  2. That character model of the girl looks horrible!

  3. Why is this rated Teen? Do the fish swear when you catch them?

  4. it’s got wifi for fish comparisions? That’s cool!

  5. I could be alone, but this sound pretty damn fun to me.

  6. I had this underwater exploration game for the Wii that was really boring. It seems like they took that game and added the ability to catch the fish, which is cool.

  7. sounds like the tried to make fishing fun. But I have to agree. Doing the same thing over and over again gets old after a while. Still, I want to try the crossbow fishing.

  8. Good review, desert. Seems very fair.

  9. Like a fish, I bit. $25.99 on Amazon w/ free shipping.

  10. That fish in the bottom pic looks pretty good.

  11. Two fishing games in a month? WOW!

  12. So I take it the only equipment in the game is Shimano?

  13. Any ice fishing? I guess that wouldn’t make for a great game, tho…

  14. Haven’t heard much of a buzz on this. I guess the “C” review is the reason.

  15. Somethings fishy about this game 😉

  16. Yep, that’s the story with most fishing games.

  17. Good review. I probably wont be picking it up until it goes on clearance.

  18. I think I’ll pass on this one.

  19. Gimme a 6pack with the game, and I am GOOD TO GO!

  20. Thanks for the review.

  21. How many different locations are in the game?

  22. I’ll rent this one.

  23. Never understood the fishing genre.

  24. I’ll be lokin fir a used copy in the next few months. I like fishing but not at full price.

  25. How many different kinds of bait/lures are there?

  26. Something fishy is going on- the top picture got changed.

  27. not much to interest me, of course I’m not into fishing in the real world.

  28. Good review. I still like the fshing gams.

  29. I might gamefly it for spits and shiggles.

  30. I catch all the fish I can eat at the local supermarket 😉

  31. Yea, not bad looking at all. I’ve seen some pretty ugly fishing games. I don’t think they spend a lot of money developing these.

  32. Looks interesting, but after the high-water mark that was the fishing controller on the Dreamcast, the Wii-Mote just doesn’t seem to stack up.

  33. I personally don’t like fishing games but good review.