The Legend of Zelda: Spirit Tracks Review

6 months ago, I remember throwing elbows to muscle DesertEagle and TideGear away from a demo copy of The Legend of Zelda: Spirit Tracks at E3.  In general, we were very civil about letting one another take a stab at whatever game we were tasked with a hands-on demo of, but in this case, my bloodthirsty side took over, and I knew I that my hands had to be the ones holding the quill-pen stylus.  I unapologetically hurled poor TideGear aside and went about piloting trains and commanding Phantoms until the demo was completely exhausted.  When Nintendo’s friendly booth guide asked which one of us would likely be reviewing the title, there was no deliberation: I demanded a copy be sent to my doorstep.

A friend of mine once told me that it seemed like we had more fun and excitement from anticipation and speculation about video games than we actually did playing the games themselves.  Although I don’t subscribe to the same pessimistic beliefs, I can agree that over anticipation can poison one’s reception.  Such was the case with Spirit Tracks.

The story of Spirit Tracks takes place 100 years after the events of Link’s previous DS excursion, The Phantom Hourglass.  Don’t worry if you’ve never played the previous installment; Link and Zelda don’t remember what happened either, so as you can imagine, it must not have much of an impact on Hyrule.  A system of ancient railroad tracks that bind an ancient, evil force, have been disappearing across the land.  Now it’s up to Link, and his ghastly girlfriend, Zelda, to restore the Spirit Tracks and recover the poltergeist-princess’ body from some nogoodnicks, who are no doubt up to no good.

Spirit Tracks does everything that a sequel should: it allows the player to relive everything that they enjoyed from the first title, while expanding the story and adding new mechanics.  The combat and dungeon crawling aspects of Phantom Hourglass remain untouched, but now, Link is accompanied by the ghost of Princess Zelda which adds another tool for puzzle solving.  In spirit form, Zelda has the power to possess Phantoms, and to mindlessly follow the path that you draw for her using the stylus.  By allowing the player to control both characters at once, Spirit Tracks combines escort missions and stealth missions; undoubtedly the two most irritating elements in gaming.  Luckily, getting separated from your Phantom never gets frustrating enough to toss the DS, and as the game progresses, Link becomes less fragile and more forgiving if you leave him out in the open.

The boat from Phantom Hourglass has been replaced by a train.  The train controls in much the same way as the boat: players plot their course by drawing a path on the map, and the train will follow it.  However, since the train has to remain on its track, traversing the land can be a bore.  Occasionally, an oncoming train or an enemy will force you to divert your course, but overall, the world map feels like one long, interactive loading screen between choosing destinations.

It may sound like I’m being hard on the game, but keep in mind that at its core, Spirit Tracks is exactly like Phantom Hourglass, which was, and still is, an amazing game.  The stylus controls are still some of the best on the DS, and the dungeons are still fun to explore.  The characters are all very charming and the story is clever and surprisingly well-written.  When this game does something well, it does it very well, but unfortunately, some of the new elements seem tacked on and dull.  If you are already familiar with Phantom Hourglass and liked it, by all means, continue the adventure and set a course for Spirit Tracks, but those who are new to Link’s Duel Screened adventures, I strongly suggest checking out his first stylus-aided quest first.

About Robert Allen

Since being a toddler, Robert Allen has been immersed in video games, anime, and tokusatsu. Currently, his days are spent teaching at two southern California colleges. But his evenings and weekends are filled with STGs, RPGs, and action titles and well at writing for Tech-Gaming since 2007.

40 comments

  1. I got this, played for three intense hours, and never went back to it.

  2. WAT? desert didn’t review this. Im shocked.

  3. I’m getting a bit sick of Zelda honestly.

  4. Good job, NOLA!

  5. We need video of you pushing TideGear or it didn’t happen.

  6. Have you guys seen that Zelda fan-made trailer?

    No need to grab this until I finish PH.

  7. How are the controls?

  8. I wish they made another Zelda for the Wii.

  9. How many dungeons are there?

  10. Good eval, Nola. Youre becoming quite the gaming critic.

  11. The graphics look pretty good.

  12. Can you believe I’ve never played a Zelda game?

  13. Whose the biggest of the bunch?

  14. Its a shame the choochoo train is the same as the tugboat 😉

  15. Anyone selling this for less than $35?

  16. I got this about a week ago. I have to agree with the review.

  17. I really liked the graphics in Phantom Hourglass, some of the best on the DS.

  18. What’s Christmas without a Zelda game?

  19. You gave Zelda a “B”.

    Oh gawd, noes!

    Just kidding. That’s the score it deserves. I beat it already. Train is boring.

  20. “The boat from Phantom Hourglass has been replaced by a train.”

    You should have left it at that.

  21. I hope to get the game with some Christmas gift cards.

  22. Does it have those stealth puzzles from the last game? Man, I hated those!

  23. Very good review, Sean.

  24. I’ll pick up this one, just like every Zelda game.

  25. The first DS game is probably my second favorite after Ocarina.

  26. I’m hoping I get Spirit Tracks for Xmas. If I don’t I’ll have to buy it for myself.

  27. I’m hoping to get a good deal on this one next week.

  28. I like Link in his conductor outfit.

  29. Alfonzo reminds me of Gonzo. Man, each Zelda game has the same characters it seems.

  30. “Now it’s up to Link, and his ghastly girlfriend, Zelda,”

    I think she’s cute.

  31. Ghastly= well, I’ll let you guess. IGN ruined it for me.

  32. I don’t think I’ll ever get used to little link.

  33. Thanks Nola!

  34. Great review. Got this for Christmas.

  35. So what price would you pay for it, Sean?

  36. Hooray, got this for Xmas!

  37. Lets just hope they change things up for the third DS Zelda game.

  38. I was hoping to score this for Xmas. I guess I’ll have to buy it myself.

  39. Great review!

  40. I would think Desert would be