School of Rock- Rock Band 3 Review

Even the savviest analyst couldn’t have predicted the impact Harmonix would have on gaming. While some might have forecasted 2005’s Guitar Hero launching an industry of plastic guitars and rhythm games in the West, few would have anticipated the specific features which would soon become obligatory for the genre. After parting ways with hardware manufacturer and publisher RedOctane in 2007, Harmonix would integrate microphone and drums set to complement the furious fret-boarding in Rock Band. Future iterations would create an oddly divergent trajectory for the genre, which changes both welcoming newbie and well as increasing the challenge for veterans. Thus, Rock Band became one of the few franchises which managed to appeal to both casual and core players.

Rock Band 3 illustrates that dual ambition near idyllically. Players who pick up the MadCatz Keyboard peripheral ($79.99 separately, or $129.99 when bundled with the game) have two major play options. In Keys mode, gamers tickly a quintet of white ivories, using the familiar note highway. Since following the falling notes doesn’t require the lateral hand movement nor the strumming of the guitar, the keyboard offers a intuitive initiation for Rock Band newcomers. On the other end of the spectrum, The variable levels within the Pro mode require oblige gamers to use each of the twenty-five keys, in an effort to simulate real piano playing. With the ability to teach players chords or arpeggios (a ‘broken’ chord where notes are played in sequence instead of simultaneously) across a range of challenge levels, Rock Band 3 can be a robust teaching tool for patient apprentices. Within a few days I was able to play John Lennon’s Imagine through route memorization- an impressive feat considering my only genuine musical performance experience was through the Miracle Piano Teaching System for the NES.

The sole drawback for budding keyboardists is the partial support for the peripheral. Although 63 of the 84 songs on the Rock Band 3 roster support the peripheral, there’s been no attempt to add key tracks to any of a player’ previous downloaded material. While adding keyboard support for guitar-oriented tracks would have seemed strained, not being able to rock out to the driving synth riffs of The Cars or Duran Duran is disappointing.

Although my time with the $150 Pro Mustang Guitar was limited, I was able to get a solid taste of what the peripheral offered. With an array of 102 buttons- which correspond to the 17 frets and six strings of an actual instrument, the device offered a complex, but faithful simulation of playing a six string. Regrettably, comprehending the game’s cascading stream of commands- filled with fret positions, and chords, was daunting. Those intrigued at the prospect of learning the intricacies of playing a real instrument may want to wait for the release of the Squier Stratocaster, an actual guitar which with the purchase of a MIDI adaptor, promises to blur the distinction between rhythm game and music tutoring tool.

For series veterans, Harmonix has made a few changes to the formula. Borrowing a mechanic from Beatles: Rock Band, the game challenges up to three singers to provide a harmonized vocal performance.  Progress is no longer is tied to a rigid single player campaign- now players unlock clothes, accessories, venues, and vehicles for their band by completing a myriad of in-game challenges throughout the game’s multiple modes. From nailing near-impossible note streaks, deploying overdrive multiple times, or simply performing five Dave Grohl songs, players are almost always getting rewarded for their actions.

Rock Band 3‘s most rewarding improvements are available to gamers willing to invest in the title’s new pro-level peripherals. For those prosperous players, Rock Band 3 has the ability transcend the trappings of the rhythm game, becoming an entry-level instrument instructor for those who have the necessary patience. For those without the funds or fortitude, the title still delivers an impressive array of songs- just don’t expect much deviation from the last game.

About Robert Allen

Since being a toddler, Robert Allen has been immersed in video games, anime, and tokusatsu. Currently, his days are spent teaching at two southern California colleges. But his evenings and weekends are filled with STGs, RPGs, and action titles and well at writing for Tech-Gaming since 2007.

33 comments

  1. So it’s more of the same, but gets an A-?

    I don’t know why Rock Band gets a free pass like this.

  2. Good review. It was smart to focus on the new stuff.

  3. thanks for letting me know about the new keyboard and guitar and keeping it short.

  4. Did you like the quality of the keyboard? It it really possible to use it keytar style on pro mode?

  5. Eww, the graphics seemed to have taken a hit.

  6. Because it’s good?

    I played a bit and it’s really fun. I like what they did with the single player game.

  7. A guy named “DeagleEagle” playing Imagine just seems wrong on so many levels.

  8. thats just the graphical effects. I don’t know why they have the same ugly screens for each site. the real game looks much better than that.

  9. Let me see a song list before I commit.

  10. “For those without the funds or fortitude”

    Class Deagle right there. I can always tell you writing style.

  11. music games are something I don’t think I’ll ever get.

    At this point, they are becoming music lessons. Why not learn to play the real thing?

  12. that brings up a good point? Is playing a almost real instrument more fun that rocking on on five buttons?

  13. Rock Out with your Keytar Out?

  14. How are the new cymbals? I was thinking about getting those.

  15. Why do the graphics look all fuzzy now?

  16. This or Kinect? I’m leaning toward RB3.

  17. So how would you score it it you don’t plan on buying anything new for the game?

    I’d like to learn more guitar, but with school I just down have the time.

  18. I’ll probably be getting this when the pro guitar comes out.

  19. They are alright. probably not worth $40 though. $25 would seem right.

  20. The 2000s

    Amy Winehouse, Rehab
    At the Drive-In, One Armed Scissor
    Avenged Sevenfold, The Beast & the Harlot
    Dover, King George
    The Bronx, False Alarm
    The Flaming Lips, Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots Pt. 1
    HIM (His Infernal Majesty), Killing Loneliness
    Hypernova, Viva La Resistance
    Ida Maria, Oh My God*
    Juanes, Me Enamora
    Metric, Combat Baby*
    Paramore, Misery Business*
    Phoenix, Lasso*
    Poni Hoax, Antibodies
    Pretty Girls Make Graves, Something Bigger, Something Brighter
    Queens of the Stone Age, No One Knows
    The Raveonettes, Last Dance
    Rilo Kiley, Portions for Foxes*
    Riverboat Gamblers, Don’t Bury Me…I’m Still Not Dead
    Slipknot, Before I Forget
    The Sounds, Living in America
    Tegan & Sara, The Con
    Them Crooked Vultures, Dead End Friends
    Tokio Hotel, Humanoid*
    The Vines, Get Free*
    The White Stripes, The Hardest Button to Button*

    1990s
    Faith No More, Midlife Crisis*
    Filter, Hey Man, Nice Shot
    Jane’s Addiction, Been Caught Stealing*
    Maná, Oye Mi Amor
    Marilyn Manson, The Beautiful People
    The Muffs, Outer Space
    Phish, Llama
    Primus, Jerry Was a Racecar Driver
    Rammstein, Du Hast
    Smash Mouth, Walkin’ On The Sun*
    Spacehog, In the Meantime
    Stone Temple Pilots, Plush
    Swingin’ Utters, This Bastard’s Life

    1980s
    Anthrax, Caught in a Mosh
    Big Country, In a Big Country
    The Cure, Just Like Heaven*
    Def Leppard, Foolin’
    Devo, Whip It
    Dio, Rainbow in the Dark
    Dire Straits, Walk of Life
    Echo & the Bunnymen, The Killing Moon
    Huey Lewis and the News, The Power of Love
    INXS, Need You Tonight*
    J. Geils Band, Centerfold
    Joan Jett, I Love Rock N’ Roll*
    Night Ranger, Sister Christian*
    Ozzy Osbourne, Crazy Train*
    The Police, Don’t Stand So Close to Me
    Roxette, The Look*
    The Smiths, Stop Me if You Think You’ve Heard This One Before
    Tears for Fears, Everybody Wants to Rule the World
    Whitesnake, Here I Go Again*

    1970s
    The B-52’s, Rock Lobster*
    Blondie, Heart of Glass
    Bob Marley, Get Up, Stand Up
    Chicago, 25 or 6 to 4
    Deep Purple, Smoke on the Water
    Doobie Brothers, China Grove*
    Elton John, Saturday Night’s Alright for Fighting
    Foreigner, Cold As Ice*
    Golden Earring, Radar Love
    John Lennon, Imagine
    Lynyrd Skynyrd, Free Bird
    Queen, Bohemian Rhapsody
    *Ramones, I Wanna Be Sedated
    Steve Miller Band, Fly Like an Eagle
    T. Rex, 20th Century Boy
    Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers, I Need to Know
    War, Low Rider
    Warren Zevon, Werewolves of London
    Yes, Roundabout*

    1960s
    Beach Boys, Good Vibrations (Live)
    David Bowie, Space Oddity
    The Doors, Break on Through (To the Other Side)*
    James Brown, I Got You” (I Feel Good) – Alternate Studio Version
    The Jimi Hendrix Experience, Crosstown Traffic*
    The Who, I Can See for Miles

  21. HighPlainsDrifter

    I’m excited for it, but I’m going to have to wait for the review before I plop down $300+ on the guitar and MIDI adapter thing.

    Anyone know of the release date for it?

    BTW- Are you guys going to review PowerGig?

  22. Id love to find a deal on the keyboard. Any know of any?

  23. As long as Jack Black isn’t on the game (School of Rock reference)

  24. Man, the 90’s were bad music wise.

  25. I noticed that also. Well, the 80’s combination of cheese and good tunes in more to my liking.

  26. I loved Rock Band 2! Now can I bring my songs from that game into this one?

  27. Whats the “*”s mean?

  28. I just want to make sure- all my GH instruments work on the PS3 version of RB3 right?

  29. I’m debating to invest in Kinect or RB3 with keyboard. Right now I’m leaning toward Kinect because it works with more games. The Keyboard only works with one game right now.

  30. That’s actually when on, if not THE best set list in any music game.

    Very cool!

  31. thanks for the review.

  32. I thought I was the only one who remembered the Miracle Piano Teaching System.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracle_Piano_Teaching_System

  33. Yeah, they look much better in game.