Life on the Edge- Borderlands Review

From Cormac McCarthy’s The Road to Mad Max, artists have often used a post-armageddon world to explore humankind’s nature. While interactive entertainment is still an emergent medium, the Fallout series has used an end of the world scenario to probe into existential matters typically left untouched in gaming. Recent release Borderlands, may not ponder on the savage nature of man, but its bleak setting makes a remarkable backdrop first-person shooter/role playing game hybrid.  The title also toys with a player’s drive for self-preservation, consistently pitting gamers against a parade of fearsome opponents. 

In Pandora, the lawless setting for Borderlands, death awaits around every corner. Traversing maps is consistently precarious, as players can stumble onto a hive of Spiderants, or into a pack of Skags, the title’s ubiquitous wolf-like enemies. Even though players can employ the assistance of up to three cooperative gamers, the game cleverly scales the difficulty level to match the expertise of the party, maintaining a skillful sense of peril throughout. This level of tension is maintained by clever deviations from FPS norms, like when gamers pick off a single opponent from a distant flock. This action will typically send the remaining mob furiously charging at the player. Expect to spend a good amount of time feverishly backpedaling, while pumping opponents with ample amounts of lead.

Fortunately, Borderlands gives gamers a boundless armory of tools to dispatch any opposition. The title’s 17 million weapon permutations means players will be carrying firearms of varying strength, recoil amount, firing speed and ammo capacity. Additionally, weapons may have scopes of varying power, and damage mods which can hit foes with additional explosive, corrosive, electrical, or fire-based effects. Unlike say, Fallout 3, the probability of any weapon hitting its target is based less on statistics, and more on the player’s reflexes. However, number crunching does come into play when calculating damage; shelling more experienced adversaries typically does a minimal amount of harm.

Borderland’s structure leans toward open-ended exploration, although an assortment of errands advances the game’s plotline. Players are tasked with the conventional fetch quests and assassinations, but a lack of any significant voice acting through many of the missions does little to elevate these errands. Forcing players to backtrack through the landscapes to collect payment seems like a way to artificially inflate the game’s length. Periodically, players will encounter the obligatory boss fight, which usually consists of circle-strafing the antagonist until your ammunition depletes.

Beyond conventional boss battles and errand fatigue, Borderland’s faults are gratifyingly minor. While the title’s vehicles remove the tedium of protracted treks across the game maps, their relationship to the environment feel artificial. Small obstacles can bring the gargantuan cars to a complete stop, making maneuvering through villages feel cumbersome. While multiplayer games are lively, the lack of a trading system means the title neglects an opportunity to create an vibrant economy out of the selling and purchasing of salvaged materials.

Visually, Borderlands utilizes a hand-drawn appearance that evokes 2007’s Crackdown. While intense firefights can cause the framerate to tumble, and the textures sporadically load slowly, the game’s draw-distance is generally superior, allowing players to see across the game’s desolate vistas. Some of the title’s effects are remarkably simple, yet intensely satisfying. When the player shoots enemies with a caustic weapon, foes emit a residual stream of numbers indicating the amount of damage taken. Seeing foes perish in a number of ways- from eruptions produced by a well-placed snipe to incineration triggered by a conflagration-based weapon, is consistently amusing.

Those seeking a solitary-oriented experience with Borderlands should be warned- the single-player game can feel unmistakably grind-heavy at times. However, those who prefer more communal diversions will likely be absorbed into the title’s well-crafted world. Borderlands is the rare game that culls from a variety of sources, competently interweaving the elements into a cohesive and satisfying package.

About Robert Allen

Since being a toddler, Robert Allen has been immersed in video games, anime, and tokusatsu. Currently, his days are spent teaching at two southern California colleges. But his evenings and weekends are filled with STGs, RPGs, and action titles and well at writing for Tech-Gaming since 2007.

55 comments

  1. I’m seeming some impressive scores for the game.

  2. I’m glad to hear it’s different from Fallout 3. I thought they were going to be similar.

  3. Great review, I’m loving the game so far. But yeah, single player does get a bit boring sometimes.

  4. I didn’t think I’d like the art style, but after a few hours, I do.

  5. You know this is really more of a FPS than RPG, besides levels.

    Still pretty decent review.

  6. I have to pick this up now. All these great reviews are breaking me down.

  7. Sorry, Borderlands doesn’t have a plot. Without a plot, you’re not saying anything about a post-nuke world.

    You just a charcters who hears voices in his head. Big wow.

  8. They need to put out a demo for this ASAP. Gearbox are you listening?!?

  9. Because I blew my wad on Windows 7, you’re going to have to wait a week, Borderlands.

  10. I still don’t understand why they changed the graphics to look like XIII. Anyone remember that one?

  11. I learned two things from this review.

    I need to read The Road before the movie comes out.

    I need to get Borderlands before I go to the bookstore.

  12. I think the review is talking about the constant threat of danger. Not knowing what could be around the corner.

  13. Yesterday was the first time in months, you guys didn’t have a new review or article.

    Don’t let it happen again.

  14. I heard the missions are pretty boring, but the game is fun as hell. Worth $50 for me.

    I’m sure I’ll see a sale before Xmas.

  15. My POS 360 redringed as I was 20 hours in. My level 28 character better not be screwed.

    Damn you Microsoft! Learn to make hardware right.

  16. Didn’t like the Road too much. Too depressing for me. There needs to a glimmer of hope in stories.

  17. 17 million guns? No wonder why Deagle liked this so damn much…

    So which is better this or F3?

  18. Isn’t that like every scary movie or ‘survival horror’ game? Whats the difference?

  19. Yeah, Metacritic has this at 86

  20. Played about 5 hours and I’m hooked. MP need a way to deal with loot whores, though.

  21. Olaf- Lost Viking

    Great review. Love the who Armageddon inrto!

  22. Next weel’s sale at BB will make Borderlands mine.

  23. Hows the enemy AI, do they take cover or are they just dumb?

  24. Hows the soundtrack?

    I heard PS3 owners are getting lock-ups, true?

  25. What sale? on Borderlands?

  26. Better than Uncharted 2? I can only get one game. Which would be the one to get

    BTW Alex from Totally Rad Show said UC2 was the best single player game of ALL TIME.

  27. Anyone notice a similarity between Claptrap and Wall-E?

  28. Got this for $39.96 (Canadian) at Wal-Fart. Woo-hoo!

  29. I wonder if they’re gonna whore this out with DLC like they did with Fallout.

  30. Bordering on Disaster

    The game borders on boring. Save your money.

    No plot, same thing over and over again, and crappy graphics. Send your $60 my way.

  31. Good review. I really want to get this.

  32. Good review. Pay no mind to the haters, people.

  33. The first hour or so left me pretty bored, then as I got used to Borderlands, I liked it more and more. Up to level 25 now.

  34. Seems like 4 player coop would be kind of limiting. 10 player coop would be all kinds of awesome.

  35. The great single player game OF ALL TIME?

    Was he high?

  36. People seem to either be loving or hating the game. Hmmm, got to try this out for myself.

  37. I’m saving my money for Dragon Age: Origins. That’s a real RPG!

  38. Wow, not a single Diablo reference? Did you do that on purpose?

    I’m actually glad, becuae all the other reviews keep menetioned Diablo to death.

  39. The Xbxo 360 version needs a patch ASAP. All kind of shit is wrong. game drops, stat screw up, etc.

  40. No one will be playing this once MW2 comes out. Trust me.

  41. I like the look of the game. Pretty nice. But I need to play it before plunking down $60.

  42. I won’t likely be playing MW2, I’ve got my fill of the games to last me a few years.

  43. So whats the cause of the armeggedeon? Nuclear War? Swine Flu?

    Looks fun, I really need to get Xbox Live again. Hopefully, the racists, and idiots have left.

  44. Very good review. Better than a magazine!!!

  45. Borderlands is probably the second best game I’ve played this year. After Batman: AA

  46. So is this one like Crackdown?

  47. i’m getting a Left4Dead from the game. Maybe it’s the coop elements of Borderlands.

  48. I wasn’t planning on picking this up, now I may have to rent it at least.

  49. Ok, this sounds officially amazing. 17 million guns? Wow!

  50. Tabasco Bloodhound

    Can you make your own guns, or just find them in the game?

  51. Nope, you can just find them.

  52. I thought at one time you could make weapons from parts.

  53. This wasn’t Armageddon; it was just a crummy planet to begin with (unless the story tells me otherwise as I play through).

  54. Ok, so the planet is Pandora, but they speak english and have guns that look like what we have on earth?

    I’m confused.

  55. Gamepro calls it post apocalyptic as well.

    http://www.gamepro.com/article/reviews/212640/borderlands/

    “Let’s face it: the apocalypse has been done to death. Nowadays, everyone and their neighbor has some futuristic tale to tell, but this innovative title from 2K Games somehow manages to breathe some new life into a somewhat tired genre.”