The Latest

Ys: Memories of Celceta Review

Ys Memories of Celceta Review (1)

Across the twenty-six year legacy of the Ys franchise, reoccurring protagonist Adol Christin has witnessed a multitude of remarkable events during his succession of globe-trotting expeditions. In many ways, the series has shared a similar fate. While the Ys titles have cultivated a fervent following in Japan, the games haven’t always enjoyed a corresponding popularity on this side of the Pacific. Beyond three releases for the SEGA Master System, TurboGrafx CD, Genesis, and SNES, it wasn’t until XSEED localized a trio of titles that the franchise starting accumulating a U.S. fanbase. Another notable incident occurred in 1993, when the series’ traditional developer, Nihon Falcom licensed the fourth installment to two separate studios. The result was Mask of the Sun and The Dawn of Ys- a pair of oddly dissimilar titles which fractured franchise canon.  Hoping to mend this schism, Nihon Falcom has created Ys: Memories of Celceta – a quasi-remake which reveals the red haired adventurer true excursion through the Great Forest.

Prudently, the recently released PS Vita title reinvigorates series’ tenets, giving each element a thoughtful reworking. The franchise’s traditional action-driven combat makes a return- this time increasing the reward for finesse amidst engaging enemy encounters and boss battles. Light role-playing components and character exposition complement the exploration and engagements, providing an absorbing impetus for the title’s twenty-hour playtime. In execution, Memories of Celceta is poised to please both series stalwarts as well as newcomers- as long as both factions make it past the title’s lackluster prologue and the occasional middling flashback.

Ys Memories of Celceta Review (6)

The game opens as Adol Christin stumbles into Casnan City- his vitality depleted by a recent foray into the adjacent Great Forest. Knocked to the ground by a passerby, the protagonist wakes up at the local bar with an acute case of amnesia, where he’s tended to by a kindhearted opportunist named Duren. Interaction between the two is interrupted, when a group on miners is attacked by subterranean creatures, forcing the duo into action. Between surviving a journey through the mysterious woodland and demonstrating prodigious swordsmanship against the underground monsters, Duran realizes that Adol is no ordinary adventurer, and soon the team is commissioned to explore and chart the Great Forest.

The introduction is overly verbose, awkwardly animated, and demonstrates some problematic punctuation- yet once players get past this setup, the game’s pace and narrative path improves considerably. Occasionally, uncovering a glimmering memory fragment reveals an expository sequence- and although these sequences often feel undeveloped, they are perfunctory and offer a stat boost as a dividend. The game’s twenty-odd main characters are generally well-developed, and the relationships that Adol forms with these people are consistently interesting. Largely, Memories of Celceta is at its best when characters are ensnared in conflict- such as Ozma- a village leader torn between tribal tradition and doing what’s best for his people.

Ys Memories of Celceta Review (3)

Although the task of cartography is somewhat linear, with sections gated off until party member capacities are uncovered, Memories of Celceta rarely feels constraining. Reconnoitering the Great Forest is accomplished with the assistance of an overworld atlas as well as an interactive auto-map. Pleasingly, the world feels vast and with little geographical recycling, the Great Forest looks pleasingly organic. As such, it’s easy to plunge into Memories of Celceta for hours at a time-as players follow natural conduits and cross large landmasses on their journey. Sporadically, the title’s routine exploration is suspended as gamers are thrust into replicating, perplexing pathways. Here, the game wants players to survey the area, looking for reoccurring features or topographical tendencies which indicate the way forward.

Although antagonists run about on every footpath and waterway, Memories of Celceta doesn’t channel the irritation often associated with role-playing’s randomized battles. Combat feels snappy and is consistently fast paced- with players issuing up combos with the square button, switching between characters with the circle, guarding with the triangle, and dashing the ‘X’ key. The latter maneuvers are essential against elevated enemies, with a well-timed defensive maneuver able to freeze enemies or increase the chances of a critical hit. Further strategy is garnered from the title’s weapon system, which classifies arms into slash, pierce, and strike categories. Using the proper offensive object can shred foes with corresponding weakness, as well as reward players with increased and improved loot drops. Additionally, players can assign and initiate customizable special moves as well as take advantage of character specific abilities, such as Duren’s ability to pick locks.

Ys Memories of Celceta Review (4)

Fallen foes (as well as their corpses), rocks, and flora release a multitude of items, which are dutifully gathered by your adventuring party. All these objects factor into Memories of Celceta straightforward crafting system, which allows players to refine a variety of materials before using these provisions to augment weapons and armor. In execution, the component allows for a surprising amount of flexibility, allowing players to construct weapons with strong stat bonuses or the ability to poison enemies. Pleasingly, Ys health regeneration system takes the burden out of potion management- normally allowing party members to heal by remaining motionless for a few seconds. Likewise, the burden of poison or paralysis is rarely life-threatening, with a trip to nearly monument or a bit of time alleviating the ailment.

Less successful is the incorporation of fast travel, which involves the use of color-coded shrines. In execution, returning to a city sporadically required multiple, time consuming steps. Ideally, these journeys would have been accomplished in a single trip- since players have to regularly return to their base of operation to obtain side quests, report on their cartographical progress, and upgrade their equipment. Later, the travel ability is adjusted eliminating the multiple-step requirement, but this amendment comes quite late in the adventure.

Ys Memories of Celceta Review (2)

Beyond the game’s core quest, inns contain bulletin boards filled with optional side quests. Some of these errands are a bit too basic. Beyond the requite fetch and kill quests, one early elective mission has players milking an exotic animal through a coarse stealth sequence. Thankfully, others assignments are more enjoyable- such as running an item shop or collecting resources in a predetermined time frame. Another agreeable ancillary is Memories of Celceta’s New Game+ option, which allows players to take their bolstered characters and items as they begin the campaign anew. Courteously, the title offers players four skill levels which influence the stringency of combat. Players are advised to start with a higher challenge setting, levels can only be decreased during play.

Visually, Ys: Memories of Celceta is consistently competent, occasionally shining in some regards. Although panoramic shots can introduce a bit of graphical showdown, the framerate during battles remains resilient. Landscapes are wondrously varied, but output during adventuring doesn’t seem to exploit the PS Vita’s native resolution- revealing the polygons which make up characters and milieus. That said, the title’s menu screens are sumptuous, exhibiting details of the six playable protagonists. Sonically, Memories of Celceta provides an array of rousing melodies, seamlessly mixing electric guitar and violin into distinctive, driving pieces. Although only a small portion of the game’s dialog is dubbed into English, the performances are notably proficient.

Ys Memories of Celceta Review (7)

Memories of Celceta is a masterful addition to the Ys franchise, offering a fetching blend of stimulating exploration and stirring, real-time combat. The game’s introduction makes an uneasy first impression, but once players pass the first half hour, the duration of the game is a thoroughly enjoyable experience. While Ys veterans will undoubtedly adore Nihon Falcom’s latest entry, Memories of Celceta is virtuous enough to add a new constituency to the franchise’s ever-growing fanbase.

Across the twenty-six year legacy of the Ys franchise, reoccurring protagonist Adol Christin has witnessed a multitude of remarkable events during his succession of globe-trotting expeditions. In many ways, the series has shared a similar fate. While the Ys titles have cultivated a fervent following in Japan, the games haven’t always enjoyed a corresponding popularity on this side of the Pacific. Beyond three releases for the SEGA Master System, TurboGrafx CD, Genesis, and SNES, it wasn’t until XSEED localized a trio of titles that the franchise starting accumulating a U.S. fanbase. Another notable incident occurred in 1993, when the series’…

Review Overview

Gameplay - 90%
Story - 80%
Aesthetics - 80%
Content - 85%
Accessibility - 90%

85%

Very Good

Summary : Along with Disgaea 3 and Persona 4 Golden, Ys: Memories of Celceta is yet another superlative role-playing adventure for PS Vita owners.

User Rating: 4.6 ( 2 votes)

About Robert Allen

With over 35 years of gaming experience, Robert 'DesertEagle' Allen is Tech-Gaming's resident worrier/warrior who spends his days teaching at three colleges and his nights devoted to JRPGs.

38 comments

  1. 85%. Third screen shows loli. Coincidence?

    (Kidding, great review, Robert!)

  2. Robert-San strikes again with a GREAT review.

    A bit of Ys history, good writing, and an A+ review.

  3. “Along with Disgaea 3 and Persona 4 Golden, Ys: Memories of Celceta is yet another superlative role-playing adventure for PS Vita owners.”

    Allright, look me in the eye and tell me the Vita doesn’t have any good games.

  4. I need to hop on the Ys bandwagon. Whats the best place to start? Are the PSP ones playable on the Vita?

    • With the Ys game you can start almost anywhere. I’d recommend Ys 7 as a good place to begin. That’s where I started then worked my around the series.

    • All of the PSP Ys games are playable on the Vita except for Ask of the Napishtem, which is disc-only.

      The obvious place to start would be Books 1&2, and the PSP version is the best collection of the two. A lot of folks suggest starting with Oath in Felghana, which is obstensively the best of the classic-style Ys games, but if you’re interested in picking up Memories of Celceta, I’d recommend Ys:Seven. Celceta uses a lot of the same mechanics and concepts from Seven, but Seven is much more polished and realized. It’s also much easier than Felghana.

      So if I had to introduce someone to the series, I’d recommend playing them in this order:
      Ys:Seven
      Ys:Books 1&2
      Oath in Felghana
      Ark of the Napishtem (if you can find it)
      Memories of Celceta
      Origins (not necessary, but if you have a PC, go for it)

      Chronological Story-order goes like this:

      Origins
      Books 1&2
      Oath in Feghana
      Memories of Celceta
      Ark of Napishtem
      Ys:Seven

      • Why is Memories of Celceta ranked 5th on the starting list?

        I think it’s just as accessible as Seven or Books 1&2.

        Also, why no two man review, Sean?

        • Oh I agree that it’s accessible but it skews a lot of the series mainstays, and I think that drops it pretty far down the list. I’d hate for someone to start with Celceta and assume the entire series was so bland and generic. The gameplay is fine, but like I said before, it’s pretty clunky compared to Seven.

          Don’t get me wrong, in not saying Celceta is BAD, I’m just saying that I don’t think it’s a very good representation of the series. That’d be like starting someone who was interested in Final Fantasy with Final Fantasy 12. Say what you will about the game’s quality, it’s not a very good starting point to get newcomers acclimated to the series. I think if Celceta were the first game I played, I wouldn’t be as excited to try the others.

          As for the 2 man review, I didn’t think I’d have time to sot and write (in preparing for a trip overseas for work) and I got my copy pretty late. Also I’m a lazy bum.

          And for anyone wondering, the first Ys game I tried was Ark of Napishtem, and I hated it. I tried the DS version of Books 1&2 years later, and that’s what got me hooked.

          • Sounds like you and Robert agree that the plot is a bit undercooked, but the action’s good, right?

            (do you guys agree on anything)

          • Glad to hear slowdown is limited to cinemas because I love Ys action combat.

          • The game doesn’t feel bland to me and I had no problems with the intro.

          • The action is noticeably slower than Seven, which was noticeably slower than previous games. The actio is slowed to allow for the addition of timed dodge/guard moves, which I actually think are pretty cool. It isn’t TOO slow, but it might be jarring if you go from Felghana to Celceta. There are noticible pauses inbetween strikes as opposed to a constant flurry of slashes.

          • How far are you? If you play as Adol and once you get into the water dungeon, things are pretty fast. At least as fast as Seven.

        • Oh, also you can buy the 1st 3 games on that list together for half the price of Celceta.

    • The PSP games are compatible with Vita, yes. Ys Seven is probably the best one to start with.

  5. I was hoping for a really good deal on Vitas this year. Sadly, no much luck on BF. Maybe Cyber Monday can get a deal on one.

  6. The question for Memories of Celceta isn’t “should I” but “Limited Edition or Regular Edition”.

  7. Love the Ys series. Played Ys: The Ark of Napishtim since I picked it for cheap back in 2006 and been hooked ever since.

    One question: is Dogi in this game?

  8. Sounds fun, but those screens looks a little blown up. IQ isn’t the best.

    • That’s a problem with all portable screenshots. The picture is bigger that the screen itself, so they look blown up and blurry. Trust me, the game looks much better in action.

  9. Well written review. Good work, Robert.

  10. I can’t find a retail copy. About to go digital.

    Anyone know if there’s an instruction booklet with the cartridge?

    • Amazon has em in stock..

      I have never played a Y’s game but bought the LE off amazon as an early xmas present for myself..Can’t wait to start playing it after reading this 🙂

  11. Good review. My Vita has been collecting dust. I might have to rescue it with this game.

  12. NIS, Atlus, and XSEED games get way too much love here. 😉

  13. Good review. I’ve been debating grabbing this. Now I think I will.

    • Now PC Gamer Presents….The KuKaLu Bird…….KOOKALOOOOOO!

      • Explain the reference, please.

        • Back in the 90s, PC Gamer came with a demo disc every month, BUT instead of just having a menu to select which demo to play, it had an FMV-style, semi-episodic point-and-click adventure game set in an office. About a year into it, the receptionist went mysteriously missing and was replaced with a talking Coconut Monkey.

          One of the things you could do in the office was check phones for messages, and there would usually be one from the PC Gamer staff just doing something dumb, and the KuKaLu bird was one of those things. It was a guy introducing the KuKaLu bird and then someone yelling “KOOOKALOOOO!”

          It’s a stretch for a reference, I know, because you would have had to

          A) Have a subscription to PC Gamer in the 90s
          B) Have taken the time to screw around with the menus
          C) Checked the phone for messages
          and
          D) Have done it in one of the 3-or-so discs that actually had the KuKaLu Bird

          but for whatever reason, when anyone mentions PC Gamer or Coconut Monkey, that’s the first thing that comes to my head. It’s a curse.

          • I remember PC gamer and all those other magazine that would come with a demo disk– before you could download demos.

            There was always a 1/20 chance that some kid would slit the cellophane, and steal the disk from the mag. I remember that happened to me not once but twice.

  14. Coconut Monkey was the old, slightly racist (vague Indian accent) PC Gamer mascot.